DIY vs. Professional: When to Tackle Window Replacement Yourself (and When to Call the Experts)

Windows: they offer light, warmth, and beautiful views, but sometimes they need an upgrade. If you’re facing drafty, cloudy, or damaged windows, the question becomes: DIY or hire a pro? The answer depends on several factors, and as experts in the field, Perfect Choice Exteriors & Bathrooms is here to shed light on the situation.

Why Consider Window Replacement

Before we dive into the DIY vs. professional debate, let’s explore why window replacement might even be on your radar:

Energy Efficiency: Old, poorly sealed windows are notorious for allowing drafts and heat transfer. New windows can make your home much more comfortable and lower energy bills.

Aesthetics: Replacing outdated windows can enhance your home’s overall appearance.

Noise Reduction: Modern windows often have improved sound insulation, creating a quieter living environment.

Increased Home Value: Window replacement can contribute to a higher appraisal value if you’re considering selling.

The DIY Window Replacement Route

There are certainly cases where replacing a small, simple window can be a successful DIY project. Here’s when it might work out well for you:

The Right Window: A small, single-pane, easily accessible window (think ground floor, standard rectangle) is the most manageable for DIY.

Your Skill Level: You have prior experience with home improvement projects and a good understanding of basic construction and window installation.

Appropriate Tools: You’ll need specialized tools and accurate measuring equipment

Important: Even DIY-suitable window replacement requires in-depth research. You must thoroughly understand proper measuring, sealing techniques, and ensuring the window is level and plumb. Improperly installed windows can lead to energy loss, leaks, and potential damage.

When to Call in the Professionals

Most situations warrant professional window installation. Here’s why:

Complexity: Large windows, multiple-pane configurations, and second-story (or higher) windows make professional installation the safest and most reliable option.

Specialized Knowledge: Professionals have extensive experience with window types, installation specific to your home’s construction, and proper waterproofing techniques.

Warranties: Professional installations, like the installations offered by Perfect Choice Exteriors & Bathrooms, often come with warranties on both the windows themselves and the labor. This provides peace of mind should any issues arise.

Energy Efficiency Expertise: Pros like those at Perfect Choice Exteriors & Bathrooms can evaluate your home and recommend the most energy-efficient windows, saving you money in the long run.

Resale Value: A professional installation can help you achieve a seamless, polished result that increases your home’s resale value.

Additional Factors to Consider

Besides the technical aspects of installing windows, there are other considerations when making your decision:

Time: DIY projects can be time-consuming. Professional installation offers a faster solution.

Safety: Working on elevated windows poses risks. Professionals have safety equipment and expertise for high installations.

Hidden Damage: During the removal of old windows, professionals might identify and address underlying issues with the framing or surrounding structure.

Choosing the Right Window Installation Company

If you decide professional installation is the way to go, selecting the right company is crucial. Consider these aspects when evaluating Illinois window installation companies:

Experience: Seek a company with a proven track record of successful installations.

Licensing and Insurance: Ensure the company is properly licensed and insured.

Product Variety: Look for a company that offers a range of high-quality window options to suit your needs and budget.

References and Reviews: Check online reviews and ask for references to learn about their past work and customer satisfaction.

Choosing the Best Path for You

The decision between DIY and professional window replacement involves your skillset, the project’s complexity, and the value you place on time versus money. Be honest with yourself about your experience and seek guidance when needed. 

Remember, professionals like Perfect Choice Exteriors & Bathrooms can often provide consultations and advice—making them a helpful resource even if you’re considering the DIY path.

The Pro Installation Process – What to Expect

Choosing a reputable company like Perfect Choice Exteriors & Bathrooms is half the battle. Here’s what you can usually expect from a professional window installation process:

Consultation: An expert should visit your home, examine your existing windows, discuss your preferences, and take precise measurements. This ensures they recommend and order the correct windows.

Window Selection: The company should help you select energy-efficient window options to suit your needs, style, and budget.

Proposal: You’ll receive a detailed proposal outlining costs (materials and labor), timeline, and any warranty information.

Installation Day: The team handles removing old windows, ensuring proper disposal. They then install new windows, ensuring a precise fit, secure weatherproofing, and proper sealing.

Cleanup and Walkthrough: The job site should be left clean. A walk-through allows you to inspect the installation and ask questions.

What to Ask Potential Window Installation Companies

Asking insightful questions helps you choose the best fit for your project. Here’s what to ask Illinois window installation companies:

Specific Experience: How many years have you been installing windows? Do you specialize in certain window types or handle home construction similar to mine?

Product Questions: What window brands do you offer? Can you help me understand the benefits of different materials (like vinyl, wood, or fiberglass)?

Energy Efficiency: How can you ensure my new windows maximize energy efficiency? Do you offer any special coatings or glass options?

Insurance and Licensing: Please provide details of your insurance coverage and licensing information.

Warranty: What are the warranties, both on the windows themselves and your workmanship?Timeline: What’s the projected start and finish date for a project similar to mine?

Warning Signs to Watch Out For

Not all window installation companies are equal. Here are red flags to avoid:

High-Pressure Sales: Reputable companies provide information and estimates but allow you time to make a decision.

Rock-Bottom Pricing: Prices that seem too good to be true often are. Quality windows and skilled installation have inherent costs.

Lack of References: Companies unable or unwilling to provide customer references might be hiding something.

“Cash Only” Deals: Reputable businesses offer standard payment options and contracts for your protection.

The Value of Professional Window Installation

While professional installation does have a cost, it often offers value that outweighs potential DIY savings:

Expertise: Professional installers at Perfect Choice Exteriors & Bathrooms possess the knowledge to select and install the appropriate windows for your home, ensuring a successful outcome.

Peace of Mind: Reputable companies stand behind their work with warranties, providing protection and eliminating concerns about installation issues.

Enhanced Curb Appeal: Expertly installed windows instantly transform your home’s appearance, giving it a polished and updated look.

Time Savings: For busy homeowners, professional installation frees up your time, allowing you to focus on other priorities.

Finding the Right Balance for Your Window Project

Ultimately, deciding between DIY and professional window replacement is personal. Carefully evaluate your skills, resources, the type of windows you want, and the value you place on professional expertise. 

Remember, a reputable company like Perfect Choice Exteriors & Bathrooms can provide guidance even if you’re initially considering a DIY route—helping you make the most informed decision for your home.

More To Explore


No time to wait? No problem – Contact us today and we’ll get started on your remodel project right away.